• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Site Logo

BasuNivesh

Personal Finance Blog

  • Home
  • Service
    • Fee-Only Financial Planning Service
    • Financial Wellness Session
  • Blog
  • Old Articles
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Media
  • Search

HNIs or Institutional Investors – Retail Debt Mutual Fund Investors SILENT enemies

July 17, 2020by Basavaraj Tonagatti

Today I was reading the news that Reliance parked Rs.35,000 Cr from Jio stake sales in Ultra Short Term or Money Market Funds The whole world discusses interest rate risk, credit risk, or default risk of debt mutual funds. However, the recessions will pose one more type of risk to debt mutual fund investors. It is Liquidity risk in mutual funds.

Debt Mutual Fund Investors Risks

The recent example of such Liquidity Risk is panic selling by HNIs in Franklin Funds leading to close the funds. However, this is not the first instance that happened in the history of Mutual Funds.

HNIs or Institutional Investors – Retail Debt Mutual Fund Investors SILENT enemies

If we go back to the 2008 Lehman Brothers crash, the biggest event happened than what the Franklin investors are facing today.

Such a liquidity risk is mainly posed by HNIs than the retail investors. This results in herd behavior among all others who invested in such funds. It may happen to your Liquid Funds also. No funds are safe if we consider Liquidity Risk.

On Sept. 15, 2008, Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy. Institutional investors knew that Reserve Primary, a money market fund, held a small position in Lehman Brothers’ debt. They were off to the races. Within five hours, YES, WITHIN FIVE HOURS! Reserve Primary had received redemption requests that exceeded 25% of the fund’s total assets.

Let me give you the choronological events that happpend on that horrific day.

On Sunday, September 14, 2008, Lehman announced that it would file for bankruptcy protection the following day. In response to this announcement, on Monday morning, September 15, 2008, the Primary Fund faced a tidal wave of redemption requests.

By 8:40 a.m., redemption requests totaled more than $5 billion. At 10:10 a.m., State Street Bank and Trust Company, the Primary Fund’s custodial bank, stopped funding redemption requests and suspended the Fund’s overdraft privileges. Although redemptions were no longer being paid out, requests continued to pour in. By 10:30
a.m., redemption requests had doubled, totaling more than $10 billion. By 1:00 p.m., redemption requests had grown to approximately $16.5 billion.

The run on the Primary Fund continued throughout the day and into Tuesday, September 16. By 3:45 Tuesday afternoon, redemption requests totaled a staggering $40 billion or roughly two-thirds of the total assets under Fund management. The run on the Primary Fund coincided with a period of enormous turmoil in the credit markets that resulted in a near freeze of trading.

Do remember two things here that the Reserve Primary Fund is the first MONEY MARKET Fund. We always claim that Money Market Funds are safe. However, leading to such huge unprecedented redemption from HNIs or Institutional Investors, the Primary Fund was forced to announce that redemption requests received prior to 3:00 p.m. would be redeemed at a NAV of $1.00 per share.

Redemption requests received after 3:00 p.m. would be redeemed at a NAV that attributed a zero value to the Lehman holdings, yielding a NAV of $0.97 per share. See id. The Primary Fund had thus “broken the buck,” becoming the first retail money market fund ever to do so.

The Primary Fund also announced a “seven-day redemption delay” on September 16, in place “until further notice.

The complete event can be read at HERE.

If you replicate what happened with the Reserve Primary Money Market Fund with the Franklin India Mutual Fund, the two events match exactly. The severity with which it happened with Reserve Primary fund may not be with Franklin India Mutual Fund. However, the end result is the same. The retail investors forced to suffer the liquidity risk because of such PANIC SELLING by HNIs or Institutional Investors.

Conclusion:-So what is the solution for retail investors to stay away from such risks? Currently, the answer is NO solution. However, as per my view, SEBI has to come out with clear notification and within the same fund, there must be two types like one for HNIs or Institutional Investors and another for retail investors (which was earlier).

I know that those AMCs who received Rs.35,000 Crore from Reliance in their funds may have REJOICED. However, such investments always post a risk to retail investors. Beware!

Read our latest posts:-

  • Interesting Tax Dispute – Whether Sachin Tendulkar Actor or Cricketer?
  • List of Index Funds in India 2021
    List of Index Funds in India 2021
  • 7.15% Power Finance Corporation NCD Bonds 2021
    7.15% Power Finance Corporation NCD Bonds 2021 – Review
  • ENEMY No.1 of your investment
    ENEMY No.1 of your investment
  • 39 Year Multimillionaire's Tesla stock value is Rs.83 CRORE
    39 Year Multimillionaire’s Tesla stock value is Rs.83 CRORE – What we can learn?
  • Best Investment Plans for 2021 in India
    Best Investment Plans for 2021 in India
Category: Mutual FundTag: Debt Mutual Fund investors

About Basavaraj Tonagatti

Basavaraj Tonagatti is the man behind this blog. He is SEBI Registered Investment Adviser who is practicing Fee-Only Financial Planning Process and also an Independent Certified Financial Planner (CFP), engaged in blogging since 7 years. BasuNivesh blog is ranked as one among India's Top 10 Personal Finance Blog. He is not associated with any Financial product/service provider. The purpose of this blog is to "Spread personal finance awareness and make them to take informed financial decisions." Please note that the views given in this Blog/Comments Section/Forum are clarifications meant for reference and guidance of the readers to explore further on the topics/queries raised and take informed decisions. These should not be construed as investment advice or legal opinion."

Previous Post: « list of Index Funds in India 2020 List of Index Funds in India 2020
Next Post: Latest BDA Plots E-auction July – August 2020 – How to apply? Latest BDA Plots E-auction July - August 2020 »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. srinivas

    July 20, 2020 at 4:03 PM

    sir
    you have not specified the name of funds and fund house in which reliance jio has invested .it will be helpful for investor like me to take a decision on redemption from such funds for safety . i have already lost a significant amount in franklin ultra fund for NPA of idea vodafone and also due to closure of the schemes.

    Reply
    • Basavaraj Tonagatti

      July 20, 2020 at 5:27 PM

      Dear Srinivas,
      It is unknown for me too. But such HNIs or Institutional Investors are always risky for retail investors. In all Funds, you will find these categories who parked their money. Hence, hard to say.

      Reply
  2. Kamal Garg

    July 19, 2020 at 10:25 AM

    Does it happen in developed countries that they segregate each debt fund into HNI/Institutional and retail category separately.
    I think it makes sense to make such kind of segregation and categorisation. Except that it will make choice much more complicated because we already have extremely large number of categories, sub-categories, etc and now we add one more.
    But I think it is worth it..

    Reply
    • Basavaraj Tonagatti

      July 19, 2020 at 10:30 AM

      Dear kamal,
      I am not sure about other countries. But this is the best move to protect retail investors.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

Newsletter Signup

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter below and never miss the latest product or an exclusive offer.

Enter your email address

Categories

  • Banking
  • Consumer Rights
  • EPF and PPF
  • Insurance Planning
  • Investment Planning
  • Mutual Fund
  • Real Estate
  • Real Life Stories
  • Retirement
  • Tax Planning
  • Uncategorized

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel

Recent Posts

  • Interesting Tax Dispute – Whether Sachin Tendulkar Actor or Cricketer?
  • List of Index Funds in India 2021
  • 7.15% Power Finance Corporation NCD Bonds 2021 – Review
  • ENEMY No.1 of your investment
  • 39 Year Multimillionaire’s Tesla stock value is Rs.83 CRORE – What we can learn?
  • Best Investment Plans for 2021 in India

Are you looking for Unbiased, Simple and Conflict-Free Financial Planning Service?

We neither SELL any product nor representative of any Insurance or Mutual Fund Companies.

We offer you an unbiased Fee-Only Financial Planning Service.

GET STARTED

    Follow along on social media

Get in touch with us here

Address: Basavaraj Tonagatti,
1446, Aastha, Sir M Vishweshwarayya Layout, 5th Block, Bangalore-560056.

Phone: (+91) 9019580450

Email: tonhokrani@gmail.com

Subscribe to our newsletter

Newsletter Signup

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter below and never miss the latest product or an exclusive offer.

Enter your email address

© Copyright 2020

Return to top