Gold and Silver ETF NAV Trap: Why You Just Lost 24% in 1 Day!

Are your Gold and Silver ETFs a ticking time bomb? Why ETFs crashed 24% while silver fell only 6%. Don’t invest bindly in ETFs without reading this article.

Are you one of the thousands of Indian investors who recently flocked to Gold and Silver ETFs to “ride the rally”? If you bought during the frenzy of late January 2026, I have some bad news: You might have paid a 12% “stupidity tax” without even realizing it.

On January 22, 2026, the Indian markets witnessed a bloodbath in precious metal ETFs. While the actual price of silver fell by roughly 6% globally, some Indian Silver ETFs crashed by a staggering 24% in a single day. How can an instrument designed to track a metal fall four times more than the metal itself? The answer lies in a concept most retail investors ignore: The Premium Trap.

Gold and Silver ETF NAV Trap: Why You Just Lost 24% in 1 Day!

The “Budget Fever” of January 21, 2026

As the Union Budget 2026 approached, rumors swirled that the government would hike import duties on precious metals. This sparked a “buy at any cost” mentality. Investors flooded the exchanges, placing “Market Orders” to grab units of Gold and Silver ETFs.

Because the demand for units far exceeded the supply available on the exchange, the market price became “detached” from the actual value of the gold and silver in the vaults.

Table 1: The Peak of Madness (January 21, 2026)

Look at the disconnect between what investors paid (NSE Price) and what the assets were actually worth (NAV).

If you bought ABSL Silver ETF that afternoon, you paid Rs.344 for something that only had Rs.306 worth of silver. You essentially gifted the seller a 12.45% profit the moment you clicked buy.

The Day the Music Stopped: January 22, 2026

The bubble burst the very next morning. Geopolitical tensions eased after U.S. President Donald Trump’s Davos speech, and the “import duty hike” rumors began to fade. Panic buying turned into panic selling.

As the “Premium” evaporated, ETF investors suffered a double whammy: they lost money on the falling price of silver AND they lost the entire 12% premium they had overpaid the day before.

Table 2: The 24-Hour Wealth Destruction

The Reality Check: While silver only lost 6% of its value, Tata Silver ETF investors lost a quarter of their capital in 24 hours. This is the danger of “blindly” chasing ETFs during a rally.

Understanding iNAV: Your Financial “MRP”

Most investors treat the stock price as the “truth.” But for an ETF, the only truth is the iNAV (Indicative Net Asset Value).

Think of it like buying a bottle of water. In a supermarket, the price (NAV) is Rs.20. But if you are in a crowded stadium (a volatile market) and everyone is thirsty, a vendor might charge you Rs.100. That extra Rs.80 is the Premium.

• Market Price: Driven by greed, fear, and rumors.
• iNAV: Driven by the actual weight and purity of the gold/silver held by the fund.

Rule to follow: If the Market Price is more than 1% higher than the iNAV, DO NOT BUY.

The “Premium-Proof” Solution: Fund of Funds (FoF)

What if you want to invest in Silver but don’t want to get cheated by exchange premiums? This is where the Fund of Funds (FoF) becomes your best friend.

A Gold or Silver FoF is a mutual fund that invests in the underlying ETF. Here is why it is safer during high volatility:

1. No Market Noise: Unlike an ETF, which you buy from a greedy seller on the exchange, a FoF is bought directly from the AMC.
2. Fair Pricing: AMCs are legally required to give you the End-of-Day NAV. They cannot charge you a 12% “market premium.”
3. The Proof: On January 22, while ETF investors were losing 24%, those who held the Silver Fund of Fund version only lost the actual 6% NAV drop. They saved 18% of their capital just by choosing the right vehicle.

Why Do These Premiums Happen?

You might wonder why the “Authorized Participants” (big market makers) don’t fix this. In theory, they should. But in the Indian context:

• Liquidity Squeeze: During a massive rally, demand is so high that market makers run out of units to sell.
• Supply Constraints: Importing physical gold/silver takes time. If the AMC can’t get more metal, they can’t create more ETF units.
• Trading Hours: Indian markets close at 3:30 PM, but gold and silver trade globally 24/7. This gap creates massive “gap-up” or “gap-down” openings that fuel panic.

Final Checklist for the Smart Investor

Before you make your next move in precious metals, follow these three BasuNivesh steps:

1. Check the iNAV: Go to the AMC’s website (Nippon, ICICI, HDFC, etc.) and look for the “Real-time iNAV.” If the NSE price is significantly higher, walk away.
2. Ditch Market Orders: Never use a “Market Order” for ETFs. Use a “Limit Order” exactly at the iNAV price. If it doesn’t get filled, so be it.
3. Choose FoF for SIPs: If you are a long-term investor doing a Monthly SIP, only use the Fund of Fund (FoF). It automates your investment at the fair NAV and protects you from the midday madness of the stock exchange.

The Bottom Line: Don’t let your “Fear Of Missing Out” (FOMO) turn into a “Certainty Of Losing Capital.” Volatility of gold and silver is different. Along with this, if you blindly invest in Gold and silver ETFs just because the whole world is running behind these precious metals, then you end up losing money rather than creating wealth.

Refer to all our articles related to Gold here –> Gold